You Only Believe Me when I'm Lying

I play it cool and act as cold as ice
 It's the only way I know to make you look twice
 'cause you only believe me when I'm lying
 I slam the door but I watch what I say
 I know it's just your jealous heart that's making you stay
 Where you only believe me when I'm lying
 And I'm not gonna send you no love letters
 'cause you'll just shake your head at the proof
 that I want you and that's the honest truth
 I've been talking to this fella next door
 Been giving him the eye, but he's asking for more
 'cause you only believe me when I'm lying
 It's hard to say exactly when I knew
 That I was on the outside looking in at you
 You only believe me when I'm lying
 And I'm not gonna send you no love letters
 Cause you'll just shake your head at the proof
 That I want you and that's the honest truth